A California school district issued U.S. high school diplomas in China to students who may not have met basic graduation requirements, and a state audit says it lacked legal authority to do so.
The audit into Val Verde Unified School District’s relationship with Pegasus California School in Qingdao was launched amid concerns about fraud and unlawful fiscal practices, and what it documents is not a loose partnership or a technical failure, but a system that issued American diplomas outside the law with no proof that the standards were met.
“VVUSD improperly issued diplomas… [and] had no legal authority to issue high school diplomas to nonresident foreign students attending Pegasus.”
That finding does not stand alone. The same audit found no proof those students earned the diplomas, cutting directly into whether those credentials mean anything at all.
“There was no evidence that Pegasus students satisfied all course requirements and proficiency standards.”
Taken together, those findings go beyond compliance issues and call into question the validity of every diploma issued through the program.
There was no legal justification for the arrangement, and the district’s “sister school” agreement, the framework used to support the program, provided no legal authority to issue diplomas.
“The agreement was purely symbolic and did not grant VVUSD the legal authority to issue diplomas.”
In practical terms, the structure the district relied on did not exist in any enforceable sense, leaving a program that issued diplomas overseas without authority, without proof, and without oversight, with no one responsible for overseeing what was taught at Pegasus, no mechanism to ensure the curriculum matched California requirements, and no way to verify student progress.
The audit makes clear that no one inside the district was assigned responsibility for overseeing the Pegasus curriculum, leaving the district without any internal verification of what students were actually being taught.
Read More: $510M AI Smuggling Case Blows Hole in U.S. Export Controls on China
China Accused of Harvesting Organs From Prisoners—And No One Wants to Talk About It
Those failures were not limited to structure. Pegasus never secured WASC accreditation and did not meet the standards required to obtain it. The audit concludes that the school would not meet accreditation standards, undermining the legitimacy of the entire program, while also confirming that non-credentialed teachers taught Pegasus students despite being presented as credentialed.
The issues extended into the people overseeing the arrangement. Consultant David Long is identified as central to both the district and Pegasus, while the district paid his firm more than $1 million as he held leadership roles inside the overseas program.
“There is sufficient evidence that Long may have engaged in fraudulent conduct, conflicts of interest, and breach of fiduciary duty.”
The audit also identifies former Superintendent Michael McCormick, describing communications showing he expressed interest in paid work tied to Pegasus before signing off on the diplomas connected to the same program, placing him within the same chain of decisions that allowed it to proceed.
“There may be sufficient evidence of fraudulent conduct, negligent misrepresentation, and conflicts of interest involving McCormick.”
Financial concerns accompany those findings, with teachers who returned to Pegasus receiving pay increases they were not entitled to, leading to the conclusion that district funds may have been misappropriated through those compensation changes.
This is what it looks like when the safeguards behind a public school diploma stop functioning.
The audit also notes that teachers returning from Pegasus were given step increases they were not entitled to after unpaid leave, tying the program directly to compensation decisions inside the district.
Pegasus marketed that program as a pathway into American universities, guaranteeing admission to a top 100 U.S. school or a refund, while district leadership told its own board that graduates would gain admission to UC Riverside, a claim the university later denied, presenting the entire arrangement as a pipeline into American higher education backed by a public school district diploma.
🚨 HUGE SCANDAL in CA schools: State audit exposes Val Verde Unified issuing REAL California diplomas to kids in CHINA who’ve NEVER stepped foot here!
Wealthy Chinese families buying spots at top US universities? All-expenses-paid trips for officials? This is a betrayal. pic.twitter.com/TYtfgQzeIY
— Sonja Shaw (@realSonjaShaw) March 18, 2026
That is where the issue moves beyond process into priorities: public school districts exist to serve their communities, funded by taxpayers to educate local students and uphold standards that give a diploma meaning.
Here, a California district issued diplomas overseas without legal authority, without proof of completion, and without oversight, documenting failures serious enough to be referred to the district attorney, the state controller, and state education officials.
A public school system that is supposed to serve American students handed out taxpayer-backed diplomas abroad, it could not prove were earned.
Editor’s Note: For decades, former presidents have been all talk and no action. Now, Donald Trump is eliminating the threat from Iran once and for all.
Please help us report the truth about the Trump administration’s decisive actions to keep Americans safe and bring peace to the world. Join RedState VIP and use promo code FIGHT to get 60% off your VIP membership.
